Performance Bond Claims Guide

Table of Contents

What is a performance bond?

What is a surety bond claim?

Who can file a claim against a performance bond?

What causes performance bond claims?

How to handle a performance bond claim

What is a performance bond?

A performance bond is a type of financial guarantee or security often used in construction and other industries where one party (usually a contractor or service provider) agrees to complete a project or perform a specific task according to the terms of a contract. The bond is a form of insurance for the client or project owner, ensuring that the contracted work will be completed as specified.

If the contractor fails to meet their obligations as outlined in the contract, the client can claim the performance bond. This claim can be made for various reasons, such as incomplete work, poor quality of work, delays, or other breach of contract terms. When a claim is made, the bonding company (usually an insurance company or a bank) compensates the client up to the amount specified in the bond. The contractor is then typically required to reimburse the bonding company for the amount paid out, as the bond guarantees the contractor's performance.

Performance bonds provide a level of security and assurance to clients that they will not be left in a lurch if the contractor fails to fulfill their contractual obligations. They are commonly used in large construction projects, government contracts, and other situations where the completion of a project is crucial and financial risks are significant.

What is a bond claim?

A surety bond claim is a legal action taken by an individual or entity, referred to as the claimant or obligee, against a surety bond to receive compensation for financial losses or harm incurred due to the actions or failures of the bonded party, also known as the principal. Surety bonds are a contractual arrangement commonly used in various industries and transactions to ensure the completion or fulfillment of specific responsibilities. Performance bonds are a category of surety bonds so understanding how surety bond claims work will help you understand the claims process for performance bonds as well. 

When the principal fails to meet their contractual obligations, such as finishing a construction project, paying suppliers, or complying with specific legal requirements, the obligee can initiate a claim against the surety bond. The claimant needs to provide evidence of the principal's breach or failure to perform and demonstrate the monetary losses suffered. Suppose the claim is validated and aligns with the terms of the surety bond agreement. In that case, the bond issuing company is obligated to provide compensation up to the predetermined coverage limit of the bond.

Surety bond claims serve as a mechanism to protect the interests of obligees, offering them a way to seek financial remedy if the principal falls short of meeting their responsibilities. It's important to emphasize that the initiation and progression of surety bond claims depend on specific conditions, terms, and procedures outlined in the bond agreement. Claimants must carefully follow these procedures to ensure the potential success of their claim.

One of the most common bond claims is contractor bond claims. More specifically, claims against performance bonds are made relatively frequently. 

Who can file a claim against a performance bond?

A performance bond claim can typically be filed by the party that holds the right to do so according to the contract terms and the bond agreement's conditions. This party is usually called the "obligee" or the "claimant." These are people who are directly affected by the project's termination or the contract's default. The three most common claimants are the following:

Project Owners or Clients

In construction projects, the project owner or client who has entered into a contract with a contractor can file a performance bond claim if the contractor fails to meet the obligations outlined in the contract. This could include failure to complete the project, subpar work quality, or other breaches of contract terms.

Government Agencies

In government contracts, the government agency or entity that awarded the contract can file a performance bond claim if the contractor does not fulfill the contractual requirements.

Subcontractors and Suppliers

In some cases, subcontractors or suppliers who are not directly party to the main contract but are affected by the principal contractor's actions can file a claim against the performance bond. This might be relevant if the contractor has not paid them or if their work was impacted by the principal's failure.

Depending on the situation's specifics and the bond agreement's terms, other parties with a legitimate interest in completing the project could also file a claim. This could include lenders, investors, or other stakeholders suffering financial harm due to the principal's failure.

It's important to note that the ability to file a performance bond claim is determined by the contract's language and the bond's terms. The claimant usually needs to provide evidence of the principal's breach of contract or failure to perform and demonstrate the financial losses incurred as a result. The bond agreement will outline the specific procedures for filing a claim and the criteria for its approval.

Need help with your surety bond?
Call 1 (888) 236-8589 to talk to one of our surety experts today.
Request a free quote online
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

What causes performance bond claims?

Performance bond claims are typically triggered by specific situations where the principal (the party for which the bond is issued) fails to fulfill their contractual obligations as outlined in the agreement. Here are some common causes that can lead to performance bond claims:

Incomplete Work: If the principal fails to complete the project or deliver the contracted goods or services as agreed upon, the obligee (the party protected by the bond) may file a claim to seek compensation for the incomplete work.

Poor Work Quality: If the work performed by the principal does not meet the agreed-upon standards or specifications, the obligee might initiate a claim to cover the costs of fixing or redoing the work to meet the required quality.

Delays: If the principal causes delays in the project's completion beyond the agreed-upon timeline, resulting in financial losses for the obligee due to extended project duration or additional costs, a claim may be filed.

Contractual Breaches: Any violation of the terms and conditions of the contract can potentially lead to a performance bond claim. This might include not adhering to legal requirements, not fulfilling specific milestones, or any other failure to meet contractual obligations.

Financial Default: If the principal encounters financial difficulties and cannot pay subcontractors, suppliers, or other parties involved in the project, a claim can be filed to cover these unpaid amounts.

Bankruptcy or Insolvency: If the principal becomes bankrupt or insolvent during the project, rendering them unable to complete the work, the obligee may file a claim to recover losses.

Abandonment: If the principal abandons the project before completion without a valid reason, the obligee might file a claim to cover the costs of completing the work through alternative means.

Non-Compliance with Specifications: If the principal does not adhere to the specifications, design, or other requirements outlined in the contract, resulting in negative consequences, a claim could be pursued.

Safety and Regulatory Violations: If the principal violates safety regulations or other legal requirements, which leads to fines, legal actions, or project interruptions, a claim might be initiated.

Subcontractor Issues: A claim could be filed if the principal's subcontractors fail to perform their duties or do not manage the subcontractors properly, causing project disruptions or financial losses.

It's important to note that before filing a performance bond claim, the claimant must provide evidence of the principal's failure to perform and demonstrate the financial losses incurred. The bond agreement will outline the specific conditions, procedures, and documentation requirements for filing a claim.

How to handle a performance bond claim

Effectively handling a bond claim necessitates a structured strategy to address the matter while mitigating conflicts and financial ramifications. Presented here is a stepwise manual on proficiently managing a bond claim:

Step 1: Evaluate the Claim 

Carefully scrutinize the claim to comprehend the fundamental issue, the claimant's requisites, and the accompanying supportive documentation.

Step 2: Seek Legal Consultation 

Engage legal specialists well-versed in the particular type of bond claim to ensure a lucid grasp of your rights and obligations outlined in the bond agreement.

Step 3: Notify Pertinent Parties 

Notify the surety company accountable for the bond regarding the claim, supplying them with exhaustive particulars, documents, and all pertinent correspondences linked to the claim.

Step 4: Initiate an Inquiry 

Commence an internal investigation to gather information, records, and evidence pertinent to the claim. Validate the accuracy of the claimant's contentions and assess conceivable effects on the project or circumstance.

Step 5: Craft a Response to the Claim 

Formulate a formal written retort to the claimant, addressing their allegations and articulating your perspective. Include any corroborative evidence or documents that fortify your stance.

Step 6: Negotiate and Reach Agreement 

Participate in constructive dialogues with the claimant to explore potential resolutions. Consider employing mediation or alternative dispute resolution methods for a mutually satisfactory settlement.

Step 7: Adhere to Bond Agreement 

Abide by the specific procedures delineated in the bond agreement for claim management, encompassing compliance with deadlines and notice prerequisites.

Step 8: Formalize Settlement with Claimant 

Upon arriving at an accord with the claimant, document the settlement's terms in an official agreement. Ensure that all pertinent parties affix their signatures and acknowledge the agreed-upon terms.

Step 9: Reimburse the Surety 

In situations where the surety company compensates the claimant, be prepared to meet your commitment to reimburse the surety in line with the stipulations of the bond agreement.

It is vital to acknowledge that each bond claim scenario is distinct, and your actions may necessitate tailoring based on specific circumstances, bond type, and the conditions stipulated in the bond agreement. Collaborating with all pertinent stakeholders and seeking expert counsel will effectively guide you through the claims process, safeguarding your interests and reputation.